In response to Tuesdayโ€™s Morning Jolt, some readers contended that the inflation rate of 3.5 percent, year over year, wasnโ€™t so bad, and that people like me should stop comparing each monthโ€™s numbers to the Federal Reserveโ€™s target rate of 2 percent, because that 2 percent goal is unrealistic.

First, for what itโ€™s worth, new Fed chairman Kevin Warsh does not think itโ€™s unrealistic. Testifying before the House Financial Services Committee this week, Warsh said, โ€œWhat you heard at our first FOMC [Federal Open Market Committee] meeting, and I hope you heard today, is weโ€™re committed to the Fed to deliver price stability. Weโ€™re committed to the 2 percent inflation goal. And so for businesses or households or market participants who came into this saying, โ€˜Well, they said before they were committed, but they seem to have tolerated a higher level of inflation,โ€™ that commitment is resolute.โ€

Second, if the White House or anyone else in government thinks a 3 percent inflation rate is good enough, and that the days of 2 percent inflation are gone forever, they ought to level with the public and say so. Right now, the president is saying the opposite. โ€œNow, inflation is way down, everything is great. We have โ€” the prices are coming down.โ€

Back in 2023, Richmond Fed president Tom Barkin warned, โ€œIf you were to unilaterally declare that youโ€™re not going to hit the target that youโ€™ve set, then you are also declaring that youโ€™re less credible in any target you set.โ€

Second, a 3 percent inflation rate has cumulative effects compared to a 2 percent one. As our John Puri wrote earlier this summer, โ€œWe can agree that 2 percent is an arbitrary target, but itโ€™s much better than any higher one. Inflation at 2 percent means that the dollar loses half its value in 35 years. Inflation at 3 percent slashes that timeframe to 24 years.โ€

Put another way, if inflation is 2 percent for the next five years, a $100 grocery store run will cost $110.41 in 2031. If inflation is at 3 percent for the next five years, that $100 grocery store run will cost $115.93 in 2031.