On Election Day, statewide questions involving abortion were on the ballot in four states. Pro-lifers scored an impressive victory in Idaho, defeating Proposition 1 by a 56-to-44 percent margin.
However, supporters of legal abortion prevailed in Virginia, Nevada, and Missouri. Amendment 3 in Missouri was of particular interest to pro-lifers. That is because supporters of legal abortion only won a narrow victory in the Show-Me State in 2024. Furthermore, pro-lifers attempted a new strategy. Amendment 3 would have not only removed legal abortion from the Missouri state constitution, but also banned transgender treatments for minors.
However, a survey conducted by the Kaiser Family Foundation provides evidence that linking a ban on minor transgender treatments to a pro-life ballot proposition may have been unwise. The poll found that 62 percent of Missourians oppose transgender treatments for minors. That said, among Amendment 3 voters, only 8 percent said the transgender issue was the more important part of their vote. More importantly, this gambit did not attract many supporters of legal abortion. Among voters who supported legal abortion but opposed transgender treatments for minors, only about 21 percent voted in favor of Amendment 3.
It should also be noted that money that supporters of Amendment 3 invested in promoting the transgender treatment ban represented resources that were not spent on countering arguments in favor of legal abortion. Furthermore, adding another issue to the ballot question may have confused some people. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation poll, 29 percent of people who voted no “said it was difficult to understand what their vote on Amendment 3 would do.”
Despite the outcome, Missouri has always had a strong culture of life. During the 1980s, Missouri was among the first states to adopt a range of incremental pro-life laws. The pro-life law that was litigated before the Supreme Court in the 1989 Webster decision came out of Missouri.
This election cycle, pro-lifers in the Show-Me State were hurt by the fact that there were no Republican candidates running statewide and the bad year for conservatives nationally. There is good reason to believe that a better campaign run in a more favorable year will restore pro-life protections to the Show-Me State.







Comments