The Corner

Raskin’s Recusal Analysis Is All Wrong

Share this story

House Oversight Committee Ranking Member Rep. Jamie Raskin (D., Md.) speaks during a House Oversight and Accountability Committee impeachment inquiry hearing into President Joe Biden, focused on his son Hunter Biden’s foreign business dealings, on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C., September 28, 2023.

Jonathan Ernst/Reuters

Charlie dismantled the separation-of-powers problems with Jamie Raskin’s one-weird-trick theory of using the Justice Department to pressure Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito into recusing from two January 6–related cases this term, Trump v. United States (which addresses Donald Trump’s claim for presidential immunity) and Fischer v. United States (which addresses the scope of a statute used against Trump and a number of other Capitol riot defendants). Let me add a few words on why Raskin is so off base on recusal itself. I’ve written before at great length on the recusal standards and will refer back to the same rules here.

First, Raskin repeatedly confuses the recusal of lower-court judges with the recusal of Supreme Court justices. The long-standing rule is that lower-court judges, at least until they’ve invested significant time into a case, are interchangeable, so there’s a stronger case for them recusing. (Trial judges also have a lot more individual discretion and power over what happens in a case than members of a nine-judge appellate panel). By contrast, because the Supreme Court must sit short-handed if anyone recuses — potentially resulting in a 4–4 tie — there’s a long-recognized “duty to sit” unless recusal is necessary. So, every single time in his op-ed that Raskin quotes or cites a judicial precedent or invokes a principle such as “doubts ordinarily ought to be resolved in favor of recusal,” he’s quoting a case where appellate courts or the Supreme Court are talking about a court below them — not about their own colleagues and not about a Supreme Court justice. He’s just applying the wrong body of rules.

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement