Andrew, the respect is mutual — and I’m a fan of Lino Graglia to boot — but I’m unpersuaded as a matter of both constitutional law and public policy. I’m happy for Corner visitors to read the links in my original post, and perhaps take a look at this short and reader-friendly law review article, and make up their own minds. And I hope that candidates, incumbents, and their staffs will do some serious research and thinking – lots more has been written – before heading down what I think is a bad road.