Andrew: This whole business is addled with superstitions, conjectures,
urban legends, and ethnic/patriotic assertiveness. Language A and language
B have lots of similar-sounding words. Why? Because they diverged from a
common ancestor-language centuries ago? Or because A borrowed a lot of
words from B? Or vice versa? Or just sheer coincidence? This is the stuff
of comparative linguistics. It’s a science, though, with very strict
evidentiary standards; and practically none of the superstitions, urban
legends etc. that you will hear about language meet those standards. (Some
of the coincidences are amazing. The word “swallow” has two utterly
different meanings in English: a verb–to draw something into the
esophagus, and a noun–kind of bird. Chinese has words for both these
things, and the two Chinese words are pronounced identically–even the
tone is the same.)






Comments