Andy, I think Obama is dealing with dueling demagoguery. There’s the domestic demagoguery against bringing the detainees into the U.S. (although, as you’ve noted, it’s hardly ideal, and the director of the FBI has concerns about it); then, there’s the foreign demagoguery against Gitmo. Push comes to shove, Democratic senators have made it clear that they’d prefer to give into the domestic demagoguery; while Obama still wants to play to the foreign demagoguery.