The Corner

Supreme Court Makes It Easier to Exclude Criminal Aliens

Share this story

The U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, D.C.

Kevin Mohatt/Reuters

This morning’s Supreme Court decision in Blanche v. Lau is probably the least of the three immigration cases that remained on the Court’s docket, but touches on a large issue: how hard the law makes it to remove criminal aliens from the country. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote the opinion for a 6–3 majority (four of this morning’s five decisions were 6–3 along the familiar ideological divide). The Court struck a blow in favor of the immigration authorities in denying entry to green-card holders where they have committed crimes but have not yet been convicted. Once convicted, if they are still here, they can be removed.

As I’ve previously framed the issue: “Green-card holders can be barred from reentering the country if they’ve committed certain crimes — but what if they haven’t been convicted yet? Can the government prove its case to an immigration judge with evidence it didn’t have at hand on the day the green-card holder tried to reenter? [Muk Choi] Lau himself, a Chinese national, is not a very sympathetic case for this, given that he unquestionably was guilty: He ultimately pleaded guilty to trademark counterfeiting [in 2013] after Obama-era immigration officials let him back into the country to have his day in court. Fourteen years later, he’s still here.”

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement