The Corner

The Fundamental Problem with Hawaii’s Black Codes Argument

Share this story

Attorney Neal Katyal outside of the United States Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., December 7, 2022.

Evelyn Hockstein/Reuters

Hans von Spakovsky has covered the bizarre assertions by Neal Katyal and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, during Tuesday’s Supreme Court oral arguments in Wolford v. Lopez, that Hawaii’s effort to severely restrict the public carrying of firearms is constitutional because it resembles the infamous “Black Codes” enacted in Southern states after the Civil War. Those laws imposed multiple burdens on the civil rights of black Americans, including restricting them from carrying firearms. Under the Hawaii law, it is a crime to carry a gun onto any private property (even by parking a car with a gun inside on a privately owned parking lot) unless the owner of the property gives explicit permission to have guns there. The Hawaii Supreme Court upheld this law on the preposterous grounds that “the spirit of Aloha clashes with a federally-mandated lifestyle that lets citizens walk around with deadly weapons during day-to-day activities.” This is probably the first time a state supreme court has defined the Bill of Rights as a “lifestyle.”

Katyal’s problem, in arguing the case for Hawaii, is the Court’s decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Assn., Inc. v. Bruen, (2022), under which restrictions on the right to bear arms are permitted only when “consistent with the Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.” Justice Clarence Thomas’s opinion in Bruen, a master class in originalist analysis, required the government to show that the restrictions it proposed were an analogue to something widely done and accepted historically — but stressed that such precedents need not be a “dead ringer” or a “historical twin.” Moreover, the occasional outlier does not prove the existence of a tradition. The Court explained in United States v. Rahimi, permitting the restriction of gun rights by people found dangerous by a court, how the test works:

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

On “The Fundamental Problem with Hawaii’s Black Codes Argument”

Advertisement

Advertisement