The Corner

The New Lobotomies

Share this story

A demonstrator holds a transgender flag at a protest in New York City, 2018.

Brendan McDermid/Reuters

Progressives claim that sex is merely a “social construct” set forth by “colonizers,” and therefore reproductive organs do not determine a person’s gender. But activists simultaneously insist that modifying (sometimes entirely removing) genitals is necessary to achieve a gender identity. The contradiction is obvious: If “gender” is divorced from sex, then why would medical interventions like surgery be necessary to affirm gender? The LGBTQ movement — given its current myopic focus on the “T” — is struggling with what we might call “Schrödinger’s sex.” Just as the cat was dead and alive, sex organs are affirmed and denied.

Andrea (formerly Andrew) Long Chu, a male who underwent surgery to construct a pseudo-vagina in 2018, notices this tension among progressives in a recent New York magazine piece, writing that “the left” has “hung trans rights on the thin peg of gender identity,” which is “a concept clumsily adapted from psychiatry.” Chu unwaveringly affirms what so many have been punished socially, professionally, and academically for stating: “Sex is real.” Chu’s insistence on a necessary ideological change within LGBTQ+ activism is reinforced through subtle linguistic changes; the essay weaves in unconventional phrases like “sex-changing medical care,” “sex-altering care,” and “sex-affirming care,” rather than the generic phrase “gender-affirming care.”

Abigail Anthony

About the Author

Abigail Anthony

Abigail Anthony is a staff writer at National Review.

Comments

On “The New Lobotomies”

Advertisement

Advertisement