The Corner

The Nikki Haley Rorschach Test

Share this story

Former South Carolina governor Nikki Haley speaks during the second Republican candidates’ debate at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library in Simi Valley, Calif., September 27, 2023.

Mike Blake/Reuters

There was no “breakout moment” at Wednesday night’s debate. The genuine disagreements on policy and substance were there if you squinted, but viewers had to sift through a lot of candidate crankiness to find them. No single candidate performed flawlessly. No one hit it out of the park. The debate was overwhelmed with cross talk, shouts, and incoherent interruptions. The moderators were simply bad in almost all respects. They repeatedly lost control of the debate. Inexplicably, they resorted to speechifying instead of, you know, asking questions. After two hours of Sturm und Drang, there were only two noteworthy developments in a night that will be largely forgotten by the end of the week.

First, in a GOP primary debate, Chris Christie, Nikki Haley, and, perhaps most notably, Ron DeSantis all attacked Donald Trump directly. Chris Christie’s attack was unsurprising, and his Donald Duck jibe landed flat. But Christie did have a memorable and genuinely amusing response to Dana Perino’s Survivor-style “vote him off the island” question. Nikki Haley had tiptoed up to taking on Trump earlier this month, and with her ongoing mini-surge in the polls, everyone expected Haley to continue her aggressive strategy. She didn’t disappoint (more on this below). DeSantis, however, showed by his attacks that his six-month-long master plan of avoiding confronting Trump directly has put him in a deep and unenviable electoral hole. Yes, there’s still a chance that his “I’ll outwork everyone else in Iowa” campaign plan pulls a rabbit out of the hat, but his newfound belligerence strikes me as a day late and a dollar short.

Mark Antonio Wright

About the Author

Mark Antonio Wright

Mark Antonio Wright is the executive editor of National Review.

Comments

On “The Nikki Haley Rorschach Test”

Advertisement

Advertisement