The past two decades have witnessed an enormous growth in social-media platforms, including platforms for discussion (Twitter and Facebook), search engines (Google), video (YouTube and TikTok), web hosting (Amazon), and fundraising and payment (GoFundMe, PayPal, Venmo). There has been an accompanying consolidation on a handful of platforms of political discussion, including journalism, debate, activism, fundraising, and advertising. Section 230(c) of the Communications Decency Act, enacted in 1996 at the dawn of the Internet age, has become a lightning rod for a larger public debate over free speech on the Internet in general and social-media platforms in particular. That debate centers around two questions: (1) Should the law hold social-media companies responsible for harmful, abusive, dishonest, or fraudulent things they don’t censor from their platforms, and (2) should the law hold social-media companies responsible when they do censor people and things from their platforms, but do so in ways that are arbitrary, unfair, or reflect political bias?
As a general legal rule, the First Amendment does not bar censorship by private actors on their own property. As a cultural value, however, if private actors can throttle citizens from participating in public debate or petitioning their government for redress, that is dangerous to the foundations on which both free speech and democracy depend. There are therefore a number of ways in which the social-media free-speech debate challenges our traditional mental models for free speech:






Comments