Regarding that Pelosi and Hoyer op-ed yesterday, I wonder what country they think they’re living in. I don’t think anyone should be shutting down town-hall meetings with chanting, etc. (it’s not un-American, it’s just rude and uncivil), but most of what seems to be going on at these town halls — hostile questions directed at nonplussed congressmen, accompanied with boisterous booing and applause — is clearly within bounds. Indeed, there are few things more American than a roiling populist revolt against an out-of-touch Congress. I just finished reading Gordon Wood’s excellent forthcoming history of the early republic, An Empire of Liberty. He describes the reaction to Congress voting to double its pay in 1816. It’s not exactly analogous to today, but Pelosi and Hoyer would surely be appalled by such a clamorous show of lack of respect for our hard-working elected officials:

Now the people had a chance to make their resentment felt. Throughout the country public meetings composed of both political parties denounced the law that had raised the salaries of congressmen. Several state legislatures along with Fourth of July orators bitterly condemned it. Glasses were raised in criticism; the compensation law, noted one New York editor, was “toasted until it is black.” In Georgia opponents even burned the members of Congress in effigy.
Critics of the raise were especially incensed at Congressman Wright’s indiscreet comment about not being able to enjoy a good glass of wine and cited it over and over to great effect. Popular outrage was unprecedented, and the reputation of Congress was severely tarnished. Even congressmen who had voted against the law had to promise humbly to work to repeal it and to return the salary they had already received. In the fall elections of 1816 nearly 70 percent of the Fourteenth Congress was not returned to the Fifteenth Congress. In January 1817 a chastened lame-duck Fourteenth Congress met to debate the issue of exactly what representation meant, and by and large it determined that the people had every right to instruct their congressmen.