The Corner

What Is ‘Cancel Culture’ and What Is Not?

Share this story

wildpixel/Getty Images

I am a routine opponent of what is often termed “cancel culture.” (To see my bipartisan “receipts,” look here, here, here, here, here, and here.) Fundamentally, I believe that our pluralist society will only work properly if we agree to tolerate one another’s views, even when we consider those views to be abhorrent, dangerous, or at odds with the presumptions on which this nation was founded. Legally, the First Amendment does not bind most of the institutions in our society, but, as a rule, we would usually be better off proceeding as if it did. America, as Fitzgerald put it, is a “willingness of the heart.” Part of that willingness is agreeing to live and let live.

I will confess, however, to being a little annoyed by the way in which the term “cancel culture” is currently being used — or, more accurately, by the way in which it is currently being flattened into meaninglessness. There is no doubt that, in the wake of the murder of Charlie Kirk, some figures have gone too far in trying to get those who cheered the killing fired from their jobs. But this does not mean that in no circumstance is it ever acceptable to consider whether someone’s words affect their suitability for employment, and it certainly does not mean that those who have consistently called out the frivolous or pre-textual invocation of “accountability” are “hypocrites” for defending its proper use. The critique advanced by the anti-“cancel culture” types was that, in the vast majority of cases, the personal views of a given American were irrelevant to the role that he or she played within our society. That Kyler Murray had once tweeted words he now regretted did not in any way affect his capacity to play football. That Brendan Eich held traditional views on marriage did not in any way affect his capacity to develop a web browser. That Alexi McCammond had expressed ugly sentiments as a teenager did not in any way affect her capacity to lead Teen Vogue a decade later. That Gina Carano once made a joke about transgenderism did not affect her ability to appear on The Mandalorian. Insofar as this is also true of those who have celebrated Charlie Kirk’s death, the same rule ought to apply. Where it is not true, however, it ought not to. To observe this basic distinction is not to “soften” or “backpedal” or “retreat” on the matter of “cancel culture”; it is to distinguish between what is “cancel culture” and what is not, in the same manner as we always have.

Charles C. W. Cooke

About the Author

Charles C. W. Cooke

Charles C. W. Cooke is a senior editor at National Review and the host of The Charles C. W. Cooke Podcast.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement