The single most important battle of the next four years — indeed, nearly the only one that really matters, given how it affects everything else — will be over the . The need to get 60 votes to enact new legislation has long frustrated both parties when they hold power, but it prevents far more mischief from the left than from the right. Republicans find themselves stymied from doing small-ball things such as tinkering around the edges of election security with stepped-up requirements aimed at reducing non-citizen voting (which is already illegal). Democrats find themselves stopped from making enormous and irrevocable changes to the nation’s political system and economy such as enacting massive new entitlements, admitting new states to the union, or packing the Supreme Court. For this reason, despite populist pressures and angry social media rants from Donald Trump, Republican leadership has held the line against efforts to abolish or defang the legislative filibuster, while Democrats have thus far stopped short of abolishing it only by a few brave dissenting votes. In 2021–22, that meant and , both of whom were hounded out of the party. Longtime Democratic institutionalists such as Joe Biden abandoned their principles on the question and have since mostly left the stage.
So who will step up now? There are still two reasons for some Democratic senators to do so. One is if they care about the institution. Without the filibuster, the Senate would take one step closer to being a clone of the House. The other is the political cost of opening the floodgates of radicalism. These midterms notwithstanding, the reality is that the Democrats’ Senate majority is built on senators in states that have been traditionally red. Some of the new red-state Democrats, such as James Talarico of Texas, are banking on their states staying blue and see no downside to openly backing radical politics, starting with abolishing the filibuster. The same is true of swing-state radical Abdul El-Sayed and of Maine’s Troy Jackson. Sherrod Brown of Ohio already backed ending the filibuster in 2021. Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota is for abolishing it. Chris Pappas of New Hampshire has dropped prior support for the filibuster. Josh Turek of Iowa says that he wants “filibuster reform” to require a “talking filibuster,” which amounts to ending the 60-vote threshold and limiting the minority to only slowing bills down; a Republican minority in particular will find it impossible to sustain a roadblock indefinitely against multiple radical bills at once.






Comments
On “Who Among Democrats Will Step Up and Save the Senate?”