The Corner

Why the Second Alex Pretti Video Matters — and Doesn’t

Share this story

Federal agents tie caution tape near the site where a man identified as Alex Pretti was fatally shot by federal agents trying to detain him, in Minneapolis, Minn., January 24, 2026.

Tim Evans/Reuters

There’s a second video of Alex Pretti getting himself into an altercation with federal agents. This one is from January 13, eleven days before Pretti was killed. It has been verified by the BBC. It shows Pretti spitting at, and then kicking the tail light out of, a federally owned SUV. Under 18 U.S.C. § 1361, that’s a misdemeanor if the damage is under $1,000, and a felony if the damage exceeds $1,000. Under 18 U.S.C. § 924(c), it is a felony if the perpetrator was armed at the time — which Pretti appeared to be.

The near-universal response to this video from those who disdain ICE has been to ask “why does it matter?” This is a fair question. Certainly, it doesn’t “matter” if by “matter” we mean “change the legitimacy of what happened to Pretti a week or so later.” That, indeed, stands alone. Pretti was shot dead in specific circumstances, not as a punishment for his cumulative actions or for being a hothead in general. That, a few days earlier, he was taped committing vandalism and interfering with the execution of federal law while armed does not justify what occurred in a later, unrelated case.

Comments

On “Why the Second Alex Pretti Video Matters — and Doesn’t”

Advertisement

Advertisement