Are You a Pedant?

Share this story

Last time, we defined the pedant as someone who ostentatiously and rather obtrusively takes pains with trifles — the type of person who takes the trouble to correct others. My late friend John Simon used to argue that it’s the public duty of every well-educated person to correct those who blunder linguistically, and I saw him do it on occasion. But when, at a wedding together, he and I heard someone say, “I can’t hardly stand this heat,” Simon stayed mum. Later, as I chuckled over his hypocrisy, he told me that he had refined his position: you don’t correct the incorrigible.

In any event, his general position is one that most people will find untenable. It’s considered rude to go around correcting people.

Bryan A. Garner

About the Author

Bryan A. Garner

Bryan A. Garner is the author of The Chicago Guide to Grammar, Usage, and Punctuation, Garner’s Modern English Usage, and The HBR Guide to Better Business Writing.

Comments

Advertisement