Brave New AI World

Our Artificial Future: What Generative AI Means for Law and Society, by David Atkinson (Cambridge University Press, 338 pp., $38) & The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State, by Jill Lepore (Liveright, 336 pp., $29.99)

Share this story

imaginima/Getty Images

Will artificial intelligence, as promoted today by the leading American technology companies, destroy our society? Apparently so, according to a pair of compelling, eloquent, but not fully persuasive books by David Atkinson and Jill Lepore.

In Our Artificial Future, Atkinson, a former researcher at the Allen Institute for AI and a lecturer on AI ethics at the University of Texas, argues that “we are essentially allowing a handful of companies to reshape fundamental aspects of how information is created, shared, and monetized, often using content created by others without permission or compensation.” He bemoans how “harms will be borne by society as a whole,” because tech companies are allowed “to externalize risks while internalizing the benefits,” as reflected by these firms’ ballooning market capitalizations. Atkinson is refreshingly candid about his priors: “I suppose you could call me an AI critic, but it wasn’t long ago that I was an absolute evangelist.” His road to Damascus crossed the wilds of copyright law, where he discovered what he considered to be the depredations of intellectual property at the hands of large tech companies. Nevertheless, he proclaims, “I still believe AI, including GenAI, can be a force for tremendous good, but I’m far less inclined to think broad societal benefits are inherent or the most likely outcome.”

Michael M. Rosen

About the Author

Michael M. Rosen

Michael M. Rosen is an attorney and writer in Israel, a nonresident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, and author of Like Silicon from Clay: What Ancient Jewish Wisdom Can Teach Us About AI.

Comments

On “Brave New AI World”

Advertisement

Advertisement