70 Year Magazine Archive

Violent Fantasy

by Jonah Goldberg

It’s not the Hollywood gore that’s the problem

Share this story

LIKE presidential elections and the Olympics, political denunciations of Hollywood violence have become a bedrock quadrennial American tradition. At least every four years—sometimes more often, if there’s a school shooting-movie-industry lobbyist Jack Valenti simultaneously sucks up to politicians and lectures them about the First Amendment. Liberal activists who denounce Joe Camel as a pied piper of social coercion swear that screen idols have no influence on human behavior. Television executives who make billions of dollars off the persuasive power of 30-second commercials declare that the 26-and 54-minute programs those ads punctuate have no net impact on their viewers.

It shouldn’t surprise anyone that there are no new arguments since the last go-around, when Bob Dole denounced “nightmares of depravity” and the “mainstreaming of deviancy” in a slew of films he’d never seen. This season, a Federal Trade Commission report—released with precise political timing—details how the film industry targets very young audiences for mature films. While this gives the controversy a newsier feel, the report’s details merely confirm what everybody knew: Hollywood makes its money from kids.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement