Career Criminalizer

IN 2002, Republicans took control of the Texas house for the first time since Reconstruction, setting in motion a process of congressional redistricting that led to the addition of five Republicans to the state’s U.S. House delegation. Shortly after the 2002 elections, Travis County district attorney Ronnie Earle launched an investigation that would touch nearly every Republican involved in the 2002 takeover. After almost three years and six grand juries, Earle has succeeded in what he set out to do: He has indicted House majority leader Tom DeLay, the man many Texas Democrats hold responsible for the 2002 takeover and the subsequent redistricting. In the process, he has used abstruse campaign-finance laws to criminalize his political opponents-and demonstrated that these laws should be repealed.

In the months leading up to the 2002 elections, a group called the Texas Association of Business (TAB) put out a series of advertisements and mailers addressing the positions of various state legislative candidates on business issues. The ads avoided using words like “elect,” “vote for,” “reject,” etc.-the magic words that, according to court rulings, change legal “issue advocacy” into illegal “express advocacy.” Instead, the group said things like “Ann Kitchen voted ‘NO’ on giving the reading test next year” and “When it comes to questions about health care . . . can you trust Raul Prado?”

About the Author

Stephen Spruiell

Stephen Spruiell is a former staff reporter for National Review Online.

Featured Tags

House of Representatives

IN 2002, Republicans took control of the Texas house for the first time since Reconstruction, setting in motion a process of congressional redistricting that led to the addition of five Republicans to the state’s U.S. House delegation. Shortly after the 2002 elections, Travis County district attorney Ronnie Earle launched an investigation that would touch nearly every Republican involved in the 2002 takeover. After almost three years and six grand juries, Earle has succeeded in what he set out to do: He has indicted House majority leader Tom DeLay, the man many Texas Democrats hold responsible for the 2002 takeover and the subsequent redistricting. In the process, he has used abstruse campaign-finance laws to criminalize his political opponents-and demonstrated that these laws should be repealed.

In the months leading up to the 2002 elections, a group called the Texas Association of Business (TAB) put out a series of advertisements and mailers addressing the positions of various state legislative candidates on business issues. The ads avoided using words like “elect,” “vote for,” “reject,” etc.-the magic words that, according to court rulings, change legal “issue advocacy” into illegal “express advocacy.” Instead, the group said things like “Ann Kitchen voted ‘NO’ on giving the reading test next year” and “When it comes to questions about health care . . . can you trust Raul Prado?”