In April 2025, at a high school track meet in Texas, two 17-year-old athletes got into a rapidly escalating altercation, or “beef,” that ended with the black athlete, Karmelo Anthony, fatally stabbing the white athlete, Austin Metcalf. Last month, after a brief trial, Anthony was convicted of murder and sentenced to 35 years in prison. His family and a group of pro bono lawyers are filing an appeal.
Like the killing itself, the verdict, reached by a jury that had no black members, raised a thundercloud of media abuse from people who have no connection to the case. In response, Austin’s father, Jeff Metcalf, appeared on various news outlets begging others not to “politicize” his son’s death. As a Christian, he says he has forgiven Anthony not so as to “give him a pass” but to free his own soul from “hate, anger, rage, revenge.” And he urged parents and schools to teach conflict resolution to children and adolescents, who “don’t have the mental capacity yet to understand how to de-escalate.” “Austin could’ve walked away; Karmelo could’ve walked away,” he added. “But that’s not what happened.”
Comments