Meet Kathryn Kimball Mizelle, the Judge Who Overturned the Transportation Mask Mandate

Share this story

Kathryn Kimball Mizelle in 2020

Jones Day/Screengrab via YouTube

Kathryn Kimball Mizelle, a federal judge for the Middle District of Florida, ruled on Monday that the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) lacks the authority to extend the federal mask mandate for public transportation.

Mizelle found that the CDC violated the Administrative Procedures Act when it implemented the mandate without the submitting to the required public comment period. She also held that the mandate lacked specificity, as it “did not differentiate between kinds of masks based on their efficacy at blocking transmission.” On top of that, the CDC did not derive the mandate from a specific line of the Public Health Services Act. The agency’s claim that the mandate was covered under the law’s “sanitation” clause doesn’t hold up, Mizelle argued.

Isaac Schorr

About the Author

Isaac Schorr

Isaac Schorr is an editor at Mediaite and a 2023–2024 Robert Novak Journalism Fellow at the Fund for American Studies.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement