From Kenneth R. Mayer, a University of Wisconsin political science professor (speaking only for himself):

The cartoon about Horowitz may be offensive, but there’s nothing for the MSA to apologize for, and no basis whatsoever for the Chancellor to reprimand them, any more than the Badger Herald should have apologized, or have been reprimanded, for publishing the Mohammed cartoons. In that case, the MSA demanded that the newspaper editors be disciplined. They were wrong then. You are wrong here.