Phil Orenstein recounts the history and status of the Academic Bill of Rights legislation in New York State and the story of how student Aaron Haberer, encouraged by this declaration of academic rights for students, fought and prevailed against a professor, Anthony Gronowicz. The professor gave Haberer a failing grade for disputing what Orenstein calls his “virulent anti-America, anti-religious demagoguery in the classroom.” Haberer filed a formal complaint, and the wrong against him was corrected.