Even before the rash of protests in the wake of the recent racial violence across the nation the volume of demands for more of what students and faculty call โ€œdiversityโ€ โ€” more black faculty and students โ€” has been rising dramatically. After the unpleasantness last fall at the University of Missouri, Inside Higher Ed reported, students โ€œcalled on administrators to increase the share of black faculty members to 10 percent by 2017-18.โ€

Another typical example comes from the Black Liberation Collective: โ€œ1) WE DEMAND at the minimum, Black students and Black faculty to be reflected by [sic] the national percentage of Black folk in the state and the country.โ€

Indeed, the influential web site fivethirtyeight.com examined in detail the demands from students at 51 colleges presented on a site called (what else?) The Demands and found that the most common demand was to โ€œincrease the diversity of professors,โ€ listed at 38 of the 51 schools. Next, at 35 schools, was to โ€œrequire diversity training.โ€

Inasmuch as the demand for black professors threatens to far outrun the supply, there are obvious logistic problems with meeting these student commands. But there is another, under-appreciated problem that will pose a difficult challenge to administrators, hiring committees, diversity trainers, and even black candidates vying to be new โ€œdiversityโ€ hires: Who, exactly, is black?

Simply being black is quite obviously not sufficient to satisfy the increasingly shrill โ€œdiversityโ€ demands. In its July 11 survey of campus responses to the recent week of racial violence, Inside Higher Ed discusses a petition circulated by Vanderbilt students to suspend Carol Swain, a controversial (because she is both black and conservative) professor of law and political science. (I have discussed her work several times, including here, here, and here.)

Swainโ€™s current offense: calling the Black Lives Matter movement a โ€œvery destructive forceโ€ in an interview with CNN.

The petition calling for Prof. Swainโ€™s dismissal also demands the creation of a mandatory โ€œdiversity training program for all Vanderbilt faculty โ€” including Professor Carol Swain โ€” to increase their cultural awareness, foster inclusion of various identity groups, prevent discrimination in the classroom, and to protect the University against inadvertent civil rights violations.โ€

It would be interesting to see what the curriculum of Vanderbiltโ€™s mandatory diversity training program would include on how to instruct a black woman professor to be more โ€œinclusiveโ€ and โ€œculturally aware,โ€ as well as who would presume to teach her. And it would also be interesting to see how the student โ€œdiversityโ€ demanders at any of the 38 colleges listed on The Demand site would react if Prof. Swain were to be considered for a position at any of them.