The Republican National Committee is spotlighting this article by Jake Tapper, โObama and Iraqi Foreign Minister Have Different Memories of their Conversation.โ
Indeed, Obamaโs description of their conversation and Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari donโt quite mesh, but thereโs no glaring contradiction of one saying โXโ and the other saying โNot X.โ Itโs more, one said โXโ, the other said โY.โ Obamaโs account suggests the Iraqis are โconcerned about their sovereignty and are not seeking a long term occupation by the U.S.โ; while Zebari told the Post that his message to Obama โwas very clear. . . . Really, we are making progress. I hope any actions you will take will not endanger this progress.โ
But thereโs a more glaring issue in Zebariโs description of the talk to the Washington Post: โHe said he was reassured by the candidateโs response, which caused him to think that Mr. Obama might not differ all that much from Mr. McCain. Mr. Zebari said that in addition to promising a visit, Mr. Obama said that โif there would be a Democratic administration, it will not take any irresponsible, reckless, sudden decisions or action to endanger your gains, your achievements, your stability or security. Whatever decision he will reach will be made through close consultation with the Iraqi government and U.S. military commanders in the field.โ
First, itโs hard to square Zebariโs description of Obamaโs remarks with the candidateโs earlier exchange in the Philadelphia debate:
ABCโs Charles Gibson: โAnd, Senator Obama, your campaign manager, David Plouffe, said, โWhen he isโ โ this is talking about you โ โWhen he is elected president, we will be out of Iraq in 16 months at the most. There should be no confusion about that.โ So youโd give the same rock-hard pledge, that no matter what the military commanders said, you would give the order to bring them home?โ
Obama: โBecause the commander-in-chief sets the mission, Charlie. Thatโs not the role of the generals. And one of the things thatโs been interesting a out the presidentโs approach lately has been to say, โWell, Iโm just taking cues from General Petraeus.โ Well, the president sets the mission. The general and our troops carry out that mission.โ
Beyond that, arenโt Obamaโs comments to Zebari โ presuming theyโre being characterized accurately โ a glaring contradiction of the Obama campaignโs constant declaration of โprofound differencesโ with McCain on the Iraq War? Isnโt a large chunk of his support from the Democratic grassroots built on this notion that a President Obama would bring the troops home quickly?
Is a trip by Austan Goolsbee to the Iraqi embassy the next step? Will there be private assurances that Obamaโs Iraq stand on the campaign trail is โmore reflective of political maneuvering than policyโ?






Comments