From yesterdayโs Jolt, since some folks loved it and some folks hated it:
Accusations of Religious Bigotry in 3 . . . 2 . . . 1 . . .
Hey, Muslim friends, we need to talk.
I know a bunch of you, both here and in Turkey. I know youโre not extremists. I know youโre the definition of decent folk. Your faith isnโt my cup of tea, but it doesnโt have to be; I know mine isnโt yours.
But this โGround Zero Mosqueโ thing is going to cause all of us a lot of problems.
Iโd like to think I would be a little wary of some sort of self-proclaimed โGround Zero Church,โ too. I donโt mean the existing houses of worship that were or may be rebuilt near that site; I mean if some flock said that they were going to move in, as close to the mass grave as possible, and build a new site, explicitly labeled as THE church of the site, to pray in the name of one faith that I may or may not share. . . . it just wouldnโt be appropriate. The meaning of 9/11 is too . . . simultaneously epic in scale and deeply, intensely personal in its impact to have part of it shoehorned into one religious institution, even for a faith as central to the events as Islam. It would feel like emotional merchandising, like some sort of Ground Zero Gift Shop.
Right now, a lot of my fellow Americans donโt see the decency in you that I do; you can ascribe that to Islamophobia or xenophobia or intolerance, but you and I know a bunch of yahoos, claiming to act in the name of your faith, keep giving them new justifications for their distrust and more reasons to dismiss all of you. The benefit of the doubt is shrinking, my friends. A lot of folk who never looked for a fight over religion wonder where the backlash is, wonder why they donโt see more Muslims speaking louder about the ridiculousness of threatening peoplesโ lives over cartoons. And if you really canโt see why Americans might recoil from a mosque at a site where the wreckage of one of those planes fell, ask yourself how you would feel about Americans building churches and synagogues, in the name of cultural understanding, where our bombs have fallen in Afghanistan and Iraq. Allegedly this mosque is being built to promote understanding and tolerance and compassion. Well, the Cordoba folks ought to try understanding why it bothers people and tolerate the publicโs touchiness about this and show a bit of compassion of finding a site a few blocks further away. Itโs not Islam in principle thatโs objectionable; Manhattanโs got a lot of mosques. Look elsewhere, guys; itโs still a buyerโs market in real estate.
Youโre a xenophobe if you want a secure border. Youโre a racist if you go to a Tea Party rally or want the Department of Justice to pursue charges against a member of the New Black Panther Party swinging a billy club outside a polling place. Put up a video that embarrasses the NAACP and a Department of Agriculture employee, and you must secretly desire a return to slavery. You oppose freedom of religion if you donโt want a mosque at Ground Zero.
Not long ago, I was on CNN with Roland Martin, who began a discussion of coverage of the DOJโs decision in the Black Panther case by declaring, โIt all speaks to motive. Fox News clearly has a motive here in terms of how they are hyping this story . . . What Fox wants, they want everyone to do what weโre doing right now, which is talk about them.โ Later that day, Kirsten Powers declared I was sexist because I referred to Abigail Thernstrom as a โnice lady.โ Notice these folks donโt engage on the facts before them; they begin the discussion by accusing the other side of sinister motives, and attempt to put the burden of proof on the other side to provide evidence that they are not, essentially, evil. Itโs like they got a memo from Spencer Ackerman or something.
Never mind having a healthy debate; you canโt debate anything with someone who operates like that. Theyโre not interested in persuading you; theyโre interested in smearing you.






Comments