Caroline Downey is a staff writer for National Review.
Caroline Downey
Caroline Downey connects today's culture to eternal truth, providing the grounded perspective for every generation.
HBO Max’s ‘Sex and the City’ Spin-Off Deserved to Fail
When a beloved, iconic television franchise returns after decades, fans expect a continuation of the sharp writing, compelling characters, and cultural authenticity that made the original a phenomenon. Caroline Downey breaks down why HBO Max's Sex and the City spin-off, And Just Like That..., ultimately deserved to fail, dissecting how the revival traded the original show's genuine humor and female camaraderie for heavy-handed "woke" virtue-signaling, forced lecturing, and alienating character rewrites. Unpacking how iconic figures like Carrie, Miranda, and Charlotte were reduced to hollow vessels for progressive tropes, Caroline demonstrates how prioritizing forced identity politics over authentic storytelling alienated longtime fans and bastardized the legacy of a classic series. What does the collapse of the Sex and the City revival reveal about Hollywood's obsession with lecturing audiences instead of entertaining them, and why forced ideological reboots routinely destroy legacy franchises? Watch Caroline’s full analysis, leave your thoughts below, and subscribe to National Review!


Comments
On “HBO Max’s ‘Sex and the City’ Spin-Off Deserved to Fail”