Genocide Lie Enthusiasts Mourn the Collapse of the Genocide Lie

Anti-Israeli activists have never had much use for factual evidence — why start now?

Share this story

Pro-Palestinian demonstrators protest outside the Consulate General of Israel, in Los Angeles, Calif., October 2, 2025.

Daniel Cole/Reuters

For all Israel’s martial acumen — its military-intelligence coups, its inventive methods for executing highly discriminating strikes on individual targets (even individual targets’ pockets), and its “astonishingly low ratio” of civilian-to-combat casualties in a fight against an adversary determined to maximize civilian casualties (according to eminent military historian Sir Andrew Roberts) — the Jewish State is terrible at genocide.

That empirical reality has long been a source of cognitive dissonance among those who know Israel is pursuing a genocidal project in the Gaza Strip but are starved for evidence in support of their conviction. While major combat operations inside Gaza were ongoing, the discrepancy was attributed to Israel’s refusal to allow Western journalists into a war zone. Now, however, reporters are surveying the post-war devastation for themselves, and what they’re concluding is not satisfying the activist class.

Noah Rothman

About the Author

Noah Rothman

Noah Rothman is a senior writer at National Review. His third book, Blood and Progress: A Century of Left-Wing Violence, was published by Hachette in May 2026.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement