Cultural Revolution vs. Constitutional Culture: The Relevance of Hamilton: An American Musical

The Hamilton musical shows the true nature of the American founding.

Share this story

Lin-Manuel Miranda greets the audience after taking part in his last performance with Hamilton in New York City in 2016.

Eduardo Munoz/Reuters

Some of those protesting and rioting in cities across the country see themselves as fighting to uphold the principles of liberty and equality that undergirded the American founding. As a naturalized U.S. citizen originally from China, I worry that my adopted country may be following a different path: that of my native country’s Cultural Revolution. My co-author, who has taught Chinese students for a number of years, shares my assessment that America’s current cultural upheaval has much more in common with China’s dark decade between 1966 and 1976 than with the American Revolution.

Mao’s young Red Guards, oftentimes joined by workers and farmers, looted and vandalized the homes of ordinary citizens under the rubric of “purifying” people’s minds. At one time, Mao’s radical warriors waged militia wars against each other and inflicted great casualties nationwide. They coerced confessions and levied harsh reprisals to crimes never committed, forcing people to hide their real political opinions and personal views.

DP

About the Author

Dr. Daniel Ping Yu

Dr. Daniel Ping Yu is an entrepreneur and the former China Director for the American Bar Association’s Rule of Law Initiative, as well as a former Senior Fellow at NYU’s US-Asia Law Institute.

JB

About the Author

John S. Baker Jr.

John S. Baker is a professor emeritus at Louisiana State University Law Center. For many years he taught, with Justice Antonin Scalia, a course on separation of powers.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement