Obituaries for fusionism are as old as their subject. Although it had precursors, this specific conception of ordered liberty was not popularized before the Kennedy administration. It was almost immediately pronounced DOA, along with Barry Goldwater’s 1964 presidential bid. The election of Richard Nixon brightened prospects for Republicans. But Nixon was explicit in his pursuit of a “new majority” that would include supporters of the New Deal and representatives of Big Business as well as theoretically inclined conservatives. Under Ronald Reagan, a fresh wind filled fusionist sails. Nearly as soon as he entered office, however, otherwise sympathetic critics began noting heresies from the old creed. And so the story goes, from the presidency of George H. W. Bush down to the present era of Donald Trump. At almost any given moment, fusionism is presumed to be dead. And yet it never is.
What accounts for this paradoxical longevity? In her new book, Stephanie Slade, senior editor of Reason, offers a careful and sympathetic history of a much maligned and often misunderstood idea. (Disclosure: I read and commented on early drafts, and I am thanked by the author in the book’s acknowledgments.) Fusionism, she contends, is not an electoral marriage of convenience between economic libertarians, religious traditionalists, and foreign-policy hawks. That was the so-called three-legged stool of the Reagan coalition. Nor was it merely shorthand for the set of figures and ideas associated with what historian George H. Nash called the “conservative intellectual movement.” Fusionism, for Slade, designates a philosophical “framework” in which virtue is the purpose of human existence, and freedom, political and economic, is its necessary condition. Slade sets out to explain where this framework comes from and why it represents the best option for meeting the challenges of the 21st century. Her attempt at a historical account is wholly welcome and largely successful. Her case for the present usefulness of fusionism is less effective, even as it remains more plausible than alternative political models that lie far outside the American tradition.












Comments
On “Frank Meyer’s Conservative Revolution”