The Darkest Knight Yet

The Batman provides an antidote to cute superhero pictures.

Share this story

Robert Pattinson (Bruce Wayne/Batman) in The Batman.

Jonathan Olley & DC Comics/Warner Bros. Pictures

The Batman is soggy, gloomy, dank, rank, filthy, and forbidding. And so I really liked it. It’s not quite as searing or unsettling as Joker, but it pushes further in that direction than any big-budget comic-book movie yet, and after the cutesy kiddie contrivances of Spider-Man: No Way Home, The Batman is as bracing as a shot of whisky after a grape Slushee.

Director Matt Reeves, who made two first-rate Planet of the Apes movies, recreates the feel of a creepy David Fincher thriller rather than an action adventure, and for three slowly paced hours the film is mostly enthralling. The sin-signifying rain of Seven drenches Gotham City, which is also plagued by murderous ciphers that recall Zodiac and Fight Club–style thug armies of disaffected youths aching to be activated in a program of terror. I don’t think Reeves is as visually gifted as Fincher, nor does he have Christopher Nolan’s ability to choreograph action scenes, so I wouldn’t rank The Batman at the absolute pinnacle of comic-book movies, but its chilling, nightmarish quality earns it a spot at the grownups’ table. The Batman certainly can’t be dismissed as yet another meretricious superhero caper.

Kyle Smith

About the Author

Kyle Smith

Kyle Smith is the film critic for the Wall Street Journal.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement