The Trans Movement Is Failing Where the Gay-Rights Movement Succeeded

By abandoning the libertarian ‘live and let live’ approach, transgender activists are alienating Americans.

Share this story

University of Pennsylvania swimmer Lia Thomas at the Women’s Ivy League Swimming and Diving Championships at Harvard University in Cambridge, Mass., February 17, 2022.

Paul Rutherford-USA TODAY Sports

The transgender and gay-rights movements are often lumped together — including in the very acronym LGBT — so many observers assume that the transgender cause will follow a similar trajectory. But there’s a reason why transgender activists won’t experience the level of rapid success that gay-rights activists enjoyed over the past several decades.

Broad acceptance of gay marriage represented one of the most extraordinary shifts of public opinion on a major social issue in American history. In 1996, the Defense of Marriage Act sailed through both chambers of Congress and was signed into law by Bill Clinton. In 2004, the year eleven states passed bans on gay marriage in ballot measures, Americans opposed gay marriage by a two-to-one margin (or 60 percent to 31 percent), according to the Pew Research Center. In 2008, the same California electorate that voted for Barack Obama by 24 points also passed a measure banning gay marriage.

Philip Klein

About the Author

Philip Klein

Philip Klein is the editor of National Review Online.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement