Yes, ‘Defund the Police’ Actually Happened

If proponents of criminal-justice reform want to be taken seriously, they will need to reckon with the failures of the policies advocated by their radical flank.

Share this story

Demonstrators calling to defund the police march during events to mark Juneteenth amid nationwide protests against racial inequality in Washington, D.C., June 19, 2020.

Jonathan Ernst/Reuters

Rather than reckon with the failures of the pervasive anti–law enforcement policies that were implemented in the wake of summer 2020, many advocates of criminal-justice reform have continually attempted to rewrite the story. The latest iteration of this is a new video posted by Hannah Cox and Brad Polumbo, co-founders of the libertarian “Based Politics” outfit, ostensibly dedicated to “debunking” Ben Shapiro’s criticisms of the criminal-justice-reform movement. In the video, responding to Shapiro’s claim that “2020 was the year of . . . defund the police,” Polumbo queries: “Also, the whole defund the police thing — did that actually happen? It was a lot of talk, but . . .” To that, Cox responds:

Cox posted the clip of that exchange on Twitter, with the caption: “The right wants to paint the entire justice reform movement as part of a move to defund the police. Not only was the defund movement always fringe though, it also never happened. In fact, most departments got pay increases.”

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement