I confess that I feel a bit whipsawed between the confused claims of liberal academics that Catholic justices somehow must be improperly indulging their Catholic moral convictions when they merely recognize that laws restricting abortion are constitutionally permissible and the confused claims of liberal academics that Catholic justices should be indulging their Catholic moral convictions to invent constitutional rights on other matters.

Update: At Mirror of Justice, Rick Garnett “cringe[s] at Prof. Dershowitz’s silly piece.”