It’s perfectly fine to quibble with this morning’s Supreme Court decision on the scope of presidential immunity for official acts, and I’ve got my share of quibbles of my own (see my column). But Democrats, the Court’s liberals, and left-leaning voices in the media are leaning into two ridiculous arguments: that this decision turns presidents into kings, and that it gives them a green light to murder political opponents without consequence.
On the first point, of course, presidents are still not kings. They can be voted out of office: If Donald Trump was a king, he would not need to ask the voters to give him his job back. They can serve no more than eight years. They can be impeached by the House and removed by the Senate. They can give orders to the executive branch to do things, and courts can issue orders to stop those things from happening. They can’t write their own laws. As the Court reminded us in just the past week, the agencies who report to the president can’t run their own court systems or decide the scope of their own authority. And presidents, like anyone else, can be civilly sued or criminally charged for their private acts, even those taken during their time in office. That’s why Trump himself is reporting ten days from now to a Manhattan courtroom for criminal sentencing over checks he wrote at his desk in the Oval Office, for which he was hauled before a jury by a county prosecutor. It’s why a state attorney general was able to sock him with almost half a billion dollars in fines.






Comments