A few weeks ago, my NR colleagues Michael Brendan Dougherty and Charles C. W. Cooke had an opinion duel about the DeSantisโDisney war. Iโve meant to add my thoughts and hope I may be forgiven for doing so belatedly, since the controversy is likely to persist and since โ as I will argue โ it raises a question of principle that extends beyond the particulars.
(Recall as background โ with thanks to Wikipedia โ that in 1967 Disney was granted jurisdiction over the โspecial taxing districtโ in which Disney World is situated. Therein it exercised municipal-like authority over such matters as โland use regulation and planning, building codes, surface water control, drainage, waste treatment, utilities, roads, bridges, fire protection, emergency medical services, and environmental services.โ After Florida passed a law in 2022 prohibiting instruction about sexual orientation and gender identity in public-school curricula before the fourth gradeยญ โ a prohibition that has since been applied through grade twelve โ Disneyโs then-CEO said that the company opposed the law and would work toward its repeal. In response, Floridaโs legislature passed, and Governor Ron DeSantis signed, a law abolishing the special district. Various plot twists followed, and the whole convoluted dispute now flows through courts.)






Comments