The essential quality of “lawfare” is the use of the legal system to impose costs on political enemies. Often, the process itself is the punishment, with the ultimate success of an investigation, lawsuit, or prosecution being beside the point. When civil lawsuits are involved, major warning signs of abusive lawfare include the assertion of technical violations of law without any proof of loss or harm to any particular person; lawsuits brought by people with no standing to sue because they have suffered no personal injury; requests for relief far broader than what the allegations justify; assertions of legal violations that don’t really exist or have no support in the facts alleged; and filings that include a lot of superfluous political rhetoric. This week brought two prominent examples: a federal class-action complaint filed Tuesday against Ron DeSantis in Massachusetts over his flight of 50 Venezuelan migrants to Martha’s Vineyard; and a civil complaint filed Wednesday against Donald Trump by New York attorney general Letitia James in state court in Manhattan.
First, the DeSantis lawsuit, which argues that Florida officials misled the immigrants in order to get them to agree to get on the plane, and told them they were going to Boston or D.C. To start with, the complaint does not inspire confidence that anybody read the thing carefully before filing it: We are told that “Plaintiffs have led lives inflicted by violence,” that they were told “bold-faced lies,” and that the defendants’ conduct “violates the U.S. Constitution and federal and states cited above.” The lead plaintiff, Alianza Americas, is an activist group based in Chicago and funded by George Soros’s Open Society network. It claims that it is “forced” by DeSantis’s actions to shift its advocacy priorities. Remember when the Job Creators Network sued Major League Baseball over moving the All-Star Game and I told readers that this same argument for Article III standing was bunk? The judge agreed, and Job Creators Network ended up withdrawing the case rather than fight the issue further.





Comments
On “Lawfare Runs Amok in the Latest Civil Lawsuits against DeSantis and Trump”