The Corner

More Lord of the Rings?

Share this story

Gandalf (Ian McKellen) in The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers.

Trailer image via YouTube

Last week brought news that Warner Bros./New Line had struck a deal with Swedish video-game company Embracer Group, which currently owns adaptation rights to The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit, to make new Lord of the Rings movies. The days since haven’t brought much in the way of specifics. But they have clarified certain details and emphasized the challenges these new adaptations of J. R. R. Tolkien’s work will face, whatever form they take.

According to the Hollywood Reporter, the deal limits adaptations to the Third Age of Middle-earth, in which The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit are set. That simultaneously gives Warner Bros. rights to the most famous characters and stories, while cutting off much of the material that has not yet been adapted to screen. (The rich lore of The Silmarillion appears to be off the table.) The Reporter construes this as a flight to the familiar; Ross Douthat might consider it more evidence of “decadence,” a society-wide inability to create anything new and an insistence on returning to the old. Maybe. But remakes and readaptations are almost as old as cinema itself. What’s different now is that filmmaking is such an expensive, risky enterprise that few are willing to gamble on anything other than surefire hits and tentpoles. The challenge W.B. faces, assuming it is mostly adapting familiar material, is to make any adaptation actually worthwhile (i.e., not simply treading the same ground) without alienating a (famously nitpicky) fanbase or turning off general audiences.

Jack Butler

About the Author

Jack Butler

Jack Butler is a former submissions editor at National Review.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement