The rule of thumb I was taught many years ago during a stint as a researcher and later an editor of investigative journalism pieces is that a newspaper’s guarantee of confidentiality to a source is not unconditional. If the source lies to you or uses you for his own personal motives, then you are released from the pact. This is a necessary codicil to the guarantee of confidentiality, because it’s the only thing that can keep a source honest. A question for the New York Times, the Washington Post and the L.A. Times, recipients of the simultaneous leak about the National Intelligence Estimate: If the declassified version to be released today reveals that you were deceived about the contents, tone and interpretation in the NIE, will you reveal who leaked the information?
Share this story

About the Author
John Podhoretz is the editor of Commentary.
Advertisement
Advertisement





Comments