The Corner

Rahimi Was about Due Process, Not Domestic Violence

Share this story

Washington at Constitutional Convention of 1787 by Junius Brutus Stearns, 1856

Public domain/via Wikimedia

In recent weeks, Iโ€™ve noticed a false narrative taking hold in the wake of the Fifth Circuitโ€™s decision in the case of U.S. v. Rahimi, a post-Bruen Second Amendment ruling that came down earlier this month. That narrative โ€” at least as Iโ€™ve encountered it โ€” is that the originalist approach that the Supreme Court has taken in some of its recent cases is irrationally gluing American law to a profoundly unlovely past. In the case of Rahimi, this isnโ€™t true โ€” and it matters that it isnโ€™t true. That being so, I thought Iโ€™d do my best to correct the record.

In Rahimi, a three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit ruled that ยง 922(g)(8) โ€” a federal law that renders it illegal for an otherwise-eligible person to possess or bear arms before they have been convicted of a crime, but while they are subject to a civil protective order โ€” is unconstitutional under the Supreme Courtโ€™s recent decision in N.Y. State Rifle & Pistol Assโ€™n, Inc. v. Bruen. Specifically, the Fifth Circuit ruled that ยง 922(g)(8) is not โ€œconsistent with the Nationโ€™s historical tradition of firearm regulation,โ€ as Bruen demands that all gun-control measures must be. Concluding its opinion, the Fifth Circuit wrote that:

Charles C. W. Cooke

About the Author

Charles C. W. Cooke

Charles C. W. Cooke is a senior editor at National Review and the host of The Charles C. W. Cooke Podcast.

Comments

On โ€œRahimi Was about Due Process, Not Domestic Violenceโ€

Advertisement

Advertisement