Kevin McCarthy has moved to bar Adam Schiff and Eric Swalwell from the House Intelligence Committee and Ilhan Omar from the House Foreign Affairs Committee. Omar’s ouster would require a vote of the full House, but Republicans’ majority means that they could remove her on a party-line vote if they remain united (which they may not); the sensitive nature of the Intelligence Committee gives the speaker more leeway. Democrats are crying foul, as if this is not precisely what they did when they had the power to do so in 2021.
This is political payback. Democrats broke with the traditional norms of the House when then-speaker Nancy Pelosi refused to seat Jim Jordan and Jim Banks on the January 6 committee on grounds considerably flimsier than those cited by McCarthy against Schiff and Swalwell, and when the Democrats voted on a party-line basis to deny committee assignments to Marjorie Taylor Greene. McCarthy has cited plausible justifications for each of his moves, but nobody has any illusions that he is taking extraordinary steps on principle due to the urgency of Schiff’s abuse of his position to spread misinformation, Swalwell’s relationship with a Chinese spy, or Omar’s notorious record of antisemitism. He is retaliating proportionally for a breach of norms by the other side. Democrats were warned that this would be the particular outcome of breaking this particular norm, just as they were warned by Mitch McConnell what would happen if Harry Reid changed the rules of the Senate on judges. Those threats are hollow if not carried out.






Comments
On “Republicans Are Right to Retaliate against Omar, Schiff, and Swalwell”