The Corner

Sotomayor Slaughters Hamilton

Share this story

Left: Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor. Right: Alexander Hamilton, portrait by John Trumbull, 1806

Jacquelyn Martin/Pool via Reuters, National Portrait Gallery

In Trump v. Slaughter, handed down at the end of June, the Supreme Court ruled that because the Federal Trade Commission exercises executive powers, the president has the power to fire the commissioners. Justice Sonia Sotomayor, dissenting, repeatedly cites Alexander Hamilton for the proposition that limits on the presidential removal power are constitutional.

On page 10, she accuses the majority of thinking it “knows better” than Hamilton (among others). On pages 15–16, she quotes Federalist No. 77, in which Hamilton says the consent of the Senate “would be necessary to displace as well as appoint” and adds, “A change of the Chief Magistrate, therefore, would not occasion so violent or so general a revolution in the officers of the government as might be expected, if he were the sole disposer of offices.” On page 19, she says that some members of the first Congress “believed (as Hamilton did) that the Constitution required Senate consent for all removals.”

Ramesh Ponnuru

About the Author

Ramesh Ponnuru

Ramesh Ponnuru is the editor of National Review, a columnist for the Washington Post, and a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.

Comments

On “Sotomayor Slaughters Hamilton”

Advertisement

Advertisement