The Corner

Speech for Me, Not for Thee

Share this story

Baker Jack Phillips speaks with the media following oral arguments in the Masterpiece Cakeshop vs. Colorado Civil Rights Commission case at the Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., December 5, 2017.

Aaron P. Bernstein/Reuters

The latest decision by the Colorado Court of Appeals ruling against Jack Phillips and Masterpiece Cakeshop concluded that Masterpiece Cakeshop had discriminated against transgender attorney Autumn Scardina on the basis of gender identity when Phillipsโ€™s wife initially agreed to bake a fairly generic pink-and-blue patterned cake for Scardina, then Phillips declined to bake it after being informed โ€” as part of Phillipsโ€™s customary inquiry into the expressive message of the cake โ€” that the cake would be used to celebrate Scardinaโ€™s gender transition. As National Reviewโ€™s editorial on the decision explained, the sequence of events makes quite clear that Scardinaโ€™s actual purpose was simply to drag Phillips into court again if he refused to bake the cake, or to undermine his position in his then-pending Supreme Court case (the cert petition for which had been granted that very day) if he didnโ€™t.

The Colorado Court of Appeals opinion rests on two premises. One is that refusing to bake the cake discriminated against Scardinaโ€™s gender identity. The other is that Phillips had no First Amendment right to decline to bake the cake because a generic pink-and-blue patterned cake, by itself, had no expressive content and is thus not โ€œspeechโ€ protected by the First Amendment.

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement