The Corner

The Only Point That Matters Is the First

Share this story

Members of the media raise their hands to ask questions as President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hold a joint press conference at the White House in Washington, D.C., September 29, 2025.

Jonathan Ernst/Reuters

As is so often the case, Andy is right. This time, he’s right about the nature of the threat that Hamas poses not just to Israel but the Western world, and the ill-advisedness of efforts to establish a durable peace in the region that disregard that terrorist outfit’s fundamental nature.

In his latest, Andy proposes a variety of causes for skepticism toward Donald Trump’s 21-point proposal aimed at drawing Israel’s post-10/7 wars to a successful conclusion. He is duly critical of the president’s apparent belief that there is always a deal to be made, even with intractable and duplicitous parties like Hamas. McCarthy is correct to observe that the plan calls for Hamas to completely reconceptualize itself, give up the hostages, and surrender its governmental and military roles on the Strip, all of which are unlikely. He’s justified in wondering why Hamas would do that, given the goodies the Europeans have bestowed on Palestinian terrorist actors merely for refusing to surrender to Israel, and he has every reason to look askance at a deal that seems to ignore Hamas’s raison d’être: the violent destruction of Israel.

Noah Rothman

About the Author

Noah Rothman

Noah Rothman is a senior writer at National Review. His third book, Blood and Progress: A Century of Left-Wing Violence, was published by Hachette in May 2026.

Comments

On “The Only Point That Matters Is the First”

Advertisement

Advertisement