The government in the Trump election-conspiracy case in federal court in D.C. has asked Judge Tanya Sue Chutkan to issue a protective order, directed mainly at barring Donald Trump or his team from publicly discussing materials turned over by the government that may be evidence in the case or relevant to the testimony of witnesses. This sort of order is routine in criminal and civil cases, but this is nothing like a routine case: The defendant is a candidate for president, being prosecuted by a government headed by his potential general-election opponent, and one of the key witnesses in the case (Mike Pence) is also running against Trump in the primary. Moreover, even when an order is routine, its scope is important, and the Trump defense offers to agree to an order barring disclosure of certain sensitive documents.
That raises the core dispute: Special counsel Jack Smith notes Trump’s long-standing habit (ongoing in this case) of “public statements on social media regarding witnesses, judges, attorneys, and others associated with legal matters pending against him.” This, Smith argues, when combined with his lawyer’s making the rounds of the Sunday shows, demonstrates Trump’s “plan to litigate this case in the media” and “could have a harmful chilling effect on witnesses or adversely affect the fair administration of justice in this case.” As Smith writes in his reply brief:






Comments
On “The Protective-Order Mess in the Trump Election-Conspiracy Case”