The Corner

The Ridiculousness of the Trump Indictment, Part Five: The Indictment Itself

Share this story

Former president Donald Trump arrives at Manhattan Criminal Courthouse after his indictment by a Manhattan grand jury, in New York City, April 4, 2023.

Eduardo Munoz/Reuters

This is the fifth and (one hopes) final installment of my five-part review of Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg’s indictment of Trump. The indictment charges that Trump made false entries on the Trump Organization books regarding his hush-money payments, made through attorney Michael Cohen, to porn actress Stormy Daniels to cover up Trump’s alleged affair with her. Part One of this series dealt with the statute of limitations. Part Two addressed how Bragg must stretch the law to transform misdemeanor false entries into felonies by claiming that they covered up another as-yet-unidentified crime — without which his whole case fails the statute of limitations. Part Three looked at more specific problems with Bragg trying to enforce federal campaign-finance rules. Part Four delved, with an additional sidebar into the New York caselaw, into why Bragg hasn’t really even laid out the basic elements of his case, which require a plan to defraud someone who would be expected to read the false entries. There may be additional problems of proof, but those are likely to emerge only if this case gets to trial. And we may yet see procedural maneuvering to get at least the federal issues heard by a federal court.

For now, however, I’ll wrap up with the problems with the indictment itself. It is simultaneously too much and too little. The “too much” part is how Bragg stretches eleven installment payments of reimbursement for a single debt into 34 separate felonies. Counts One through Four of the indictment present an especially egregious example of overcharging. On February 14, 2017 (a date doubtless chosen by Trump and Cohen because they are such hopeless romantics about porn-star-affair hush money), Cohen sent Trump an invoice, and Trump wrote him a check, which was recorded in two places in the Detail General Ledger for the Donald J. Trump Revocable Trust. Bragg charges this as four separate felonies: one for the invoice, one for the check, and one for each of the ledger entries. I’m surprised he didn’t charge Trump in a separate count for every zero on the check.

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement