The Corner

TikTok’s Bad Day at the Supreme Court

Share this story

Marko Djurica/Reuters

The Supreme Court has been hearing arguments this morning on whether to uphold the federal law requiring the Chinese company ByteDance to either divest from TikTok or cease operating the platform in the United States. Based on how the arguments went, there may not be even a single vote to strike down the law or even pause it until Donald Trump can be sworn in.

The likeliest basis for the Court to rule is the concern that TikTok is gathering information on Americans, and that this is being done by a foreign entity linked to a hostile foreign government. Oddly, it took nearly 40 minutes into the argument for that issue to come up, but the justices piled on Noel Francisco, the former solicitor general, arguing for TikTok, and Jeffrey Fisher, arguing on behalf of TikTok users, on the data collection issue. Justice Samuel Alito pinned down Francisco on two points: that his argument for TikTok’s First Amendment rights wouldn’t stand up if TikTok was directly controlled by the Chinese government, and that he wouldn’t have an argument about discrimination against TikTok’s speech if Congress had premised its law only on data security concerns. Justice Brett Kavanaugh asked Francisco whether it is really an unrealistic concern to think that if you collect information on people in their teens or twenties, that this information might be used against them later in life when they work for the government. (This, from a man who was almost kept off the Court based on allegations from his high school years.) As Kavanaugh said of the data collection issue, “That seems like a huge concern for the future of the country.”

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

On “TikTok’s Bad Day at the Supreme Court”

Advertisement

Advertisement