The Corner

Why Arguments against the House TikTok Bill Don’t Survive Contact with Reality

Share this story

Rep. Robert Garcia (D., Calif.) speaks as he is joined by fellow House members Rep. Maxwell Frost (D., Fla.), Rep. Sara Jacobs (D., Calif.), Rep. Delia Ramirez (D., Ill.) and TikTok creators during a press conference to voice their opposition to the “Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act“ legislation on TikTok on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C., March 12, 2024.

Craig Hudson/Reuters

Almost exactly one year ago, when the U.S. Senate was debating the RESTRICT Act — sold by its authors as a means of “banning TikTok” — I first savaged the app as an ungated cloaca of demotic sludge warping hypnotized teens with infinite content, and all but recommended taking off and nuking it from orbit as the only way to be sure.

But then I turned to the real issue, which was how repulsive the RESTRICT Act itself was, a sweepingly overbroad and alarmingly drafted mess that honestly read, with its vaguely general authorizations and ill-defined terminology, like a paranoiac’s fever-dream-come-true: Trojan horse legislation designed to allow an unaccountable executive branch to arbitrarily interfere with American political and social discourse in the name of vaguely defined “national security,” sold to us under false pretenses. No matter how serious the threat posed by TikTok — and it is a grave one, as ably summarized by the Editors earlier this week — I argued that it was not worth yielding such dangerous powers to the executive branch in what felt like an obvious invitation to governmental abuse. The Senate bill quietly died, and will thankfully not return.

JB

About the Author

Jeffrey Blehar

Jeffrey Blehar is a National Review staff writer living in Chicago. He is also the co-host of National Review’s Political Beats podcast, which explores the great music of the modern era with guests from the political world happy to find something non-political to talk about.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement