Check the Label

THERE are few liberal tics I hate more than the pronouncement “I don’t believe in labels.” Liberals seem not to like being tagged and marked for what they are because they don’t like to be hemmed in. This reflex has a long intellectual pedigree, but its most recent direct antecedent is JFK’s “new politics,” which revolved around his claim that most of the ideological questions of the day had been settled and all that was left was for technocratic brainiacs-like him-to work out the details in some government office somewhere.

Since then, liberals have employed versions of this locution whenever they have gotten boxed in by labels. They are “post-partisan,” they claim. Many liberals refuse to admit that liberalism means anything more or less than “the right thing.” This is essentially the definition preferred by Jonathan Chait at The New Republic. Hillary Clinton is fond of saying, for example, that we need to move “beyond” labels and ideology and get down to problem-solving. Translation: Stop objecting to my ideas and help me implement them.

About the Author

Jonah Goldberg

Jonah Goldberg is a National Review contributing editor.

Featured Tags

THERE are few liberal tics I hate more than the pronouncement “I don’t believe in labels.” Liberals seem not to like being tagged and marked for what they are because they don’t like to be hemmed in. This reflex has a long intellectual pedigree, but its most recent direct antecedent is JFK’s “new politics,” which revolved around his claim that most of the ideological questions of the day had been settled and all that was left was for technocratic brainiacs-like him-to work out the details in some government office somewhere.

Since then, liberals have employed versions of this locution whenever they have gotten boxed in by labels. They are “post-partisan,” they claim. Many liberals refuse to admit that liberalism means anything more or less than “the right thing.” This is essentially the definition preferred by Jonathan Chait at The New Republic. Hillary Clinton is fond of saying, for example, that we need to move “beyond” labels and ideology and get down to problem-solving. Translation: Stop objecting to my ideas and help me implement them.