With Republicans having lost their congressional majority, a vicious internecine battle has commenced to redefine the principles and parameters of the American right. Vice President JD Vance points to the Iran war as the cause of the wipeout and seeks to reposition the GOP’s foreign policy. The right’s free-market remnant, meanwhile, has seized on voters’ cost-of-living discontent, making tariffs and economic protectionism its target. Yet it is the resolution of another matter — noxiously dubbed the “Indian question” — that will best indicate the Republican Party’s new direction. Wrapped up in it are the related, yet distinct, issues of immigration, assimilation, economics, and the very nature of the polity.
Fomented in the heady days following Donald Trump’s 2024 presidential election, launched into public awareness by a candidate for public office this September, and given full form by a podcasting duo a couple of weeks later, the “Indian question” divides the right into two camps: one for whom American nationalism is pluralistic and civic in character, and another for whom it is exclusive and identity-bound.












Comments
On “Republicans Must Reject Anti-Indian Bigotry”